The story:
Canada ’s Minister of Natural Resources, Joe Oliver, has become the latest politician to blame the United States for problems affecting his own country.
At issue is the so-called “Gateway” pipeline from Alberta to British Columbia that, if built, would allow Canada to ship Alberta tar sands products to Asia .
Canada ’s Stephen Harper Conservative government has emulated the world’s most discredited and despised right-wing dictators by blaming domestic shortcomings on U.S. interference.
Piqued by an American deferral of the “Keystone” pipeline, which would run north from Alberta south to the Gulf of Mexico, the Harperites, as they are known in Canada , thought they’d play a little hardball with the U.S. and say that Canada would take its oil and ship it to China as a result of U.S. dithering over environmental concerns.
What the Harper government knew, though, was that there was already plenty of opposition to a Canadian pipeline across territory that includes First Nations (Indian) land. In an effort to get out in front of any opposition, the Harper government, in the voice of hapless Joe Oliver, decided to blame environmentalist American “billionaire socialists” (warning: massive CBC advertising amplification!! http://www.cbc.ca/video/#/News/TV_Shows/The_National/1233408557/ID=2185209491) for any potential impediments to the east-west Canadian pipeline.
Just one part of the reason Minister Oliver could not rail against his own citizens (Natives) was because they’d already shown themselves to be fairly savvy with respect to business and resource deals, and had in fact made agreements that didn’t involve pipelines. Can’t criticize at home, better go abroad, is what Joe was counseled.
The implications:
By so doing, the Harper government has become just the latest one to blame the U.S. for pretty well everything. Typically, I’m right out in front of that one; I’m ready to blame the U.S. for just about anything, and generally the U.S. richly deserves it. There are big and/or powerful countries out there, besides the U.S. , that don’t choose to bankrupt themselves by meddling in other countries.
Look at the dismaying cartoon strip that is U.S. politics. I’d like to go on. But sometimes, you do have to feel for the U.S. , which does contain some good and sensible people that you don’t see on TV every night. And here’s good ol’ Joe Oliver, Canadian government minister, joining every tin-pot dictator and knee-jerk wingnut in condemning the U.S. for messing up Canada ’s *own* pipeline dreams.
In an interview with a Canadian radio show (http://www.cbc.ca/asithappens/episode/2012/01/09/the-monday-edition-8/), barely coherent (drunk, sleep-deprived, IQ of 74?) Joe refused to (obviously couldn’t) identify the “billionaire socialists” he’d named above. He dismissed the fact that fewer than 20 of 4500 of those who signed up to comment on Gateway were American; the rest, he implied (he used the word “parrot”), were merely the equivalent of those who signed petitions (grassroots democracy is a hell of a thing, as Stockwell “Doris” Day found out early). Meanwhile, of the 250 or so intervenors—those who are allowed to ask questions and not merely offer a few words of comment—multinationals like Exxon figured remarkably prominently.
Speaking of parroting, Oliver’s contemptuous term for democracy, one could note how, in his own open letter, Oliver slavishly emulates Newt Gingrich, the man who has been, in books and speeches, indeed in marriages, standing “at a crossroads” for some decades now: “Canada is on the edge of an historic choice,” the Minister intones. For his full letter, read here: http://www.nrcan.gc.ca/media-room/news-release/2012/1/3520. It’s probably worthwhile reading since, because the Minister himself probably doesn’t have a clue what it says, it may give you a random point on a map from which you can then re-orient yourself towards whatever thoughts the Minister may have but is not likely to reveal (unless Harper tells/lets him/gets around to reading them first).
Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his Conservative government, through Minister Joe Oliver, are attempting to cheapen and debase Canadian politics once again, by making outlandish claims about U.S. “billionaire socialists” that they can’t substantiate and honestly never really intended to try to. (And they probably got scared like hell by lawyers, and that only shows what hick rubes they really are.) Using the Assad mode, Harper is trying to blame foreign interference in Canadian affairs. Oliver, parroting Kim Jong-il, is attempting to suggest that it is the U.S. that is attempting to undermine the Canadian state, and thus build up Canadian support for projects that, in democracies, would come under public scrutiny.
A Handful of Hard Facts:
It may be that, relatively speaking, pipelines don’t present so much incredible danger. In the sense that a loaded gun pointed at your head if the trigger isn’t pulled doesn’t present danger, or a bathtub full of water won’t empty if you don’t pull the plug, surely pipelines don’t present much danger. But Americans just watched an Enbridge pipeline spill into a Michigan river, so how could anyone expect Oklahomans to leap with gaiety at the thought of a TransCanada spill in their own aquifers?
As Natives point out, one massive oil spill off Kitimat could have ramifications for generations or more—this—this merits Minister Oliver’s contempt. A man who probably couldn’t find Kitimat on a map with oven mitts is now in charge of it. There is much to fear.
Get serious, Canada, you don’t even own the sludge you want to export, anyway; China sure as hell isn’t going to wait on a pipeline when it can just come over and buy pretty much anything it wants and mock Canadian energy sovereignty: http://www.calgaryherald.com/business/Chinese+firm+buys+full+stake+oilsands+project/5943628/story.html Canadians might just as well live in Guangdong and murder dissidents and serve tea while they’re at it for all Minister Oliver knows or cares about his file.
Gutless Joe Oliver, in defense of the American multinationals (not those chimerical “billionaire socialists”) he wants to build Canadian pipelines, quails and wheedles and whinges that Canada just doesn’t have what it takes to develop its own tar sands. You go tell Tommy Douglas, or Lester Pearson, or, for that matter, John A. Macdonald, that. (In his letter, that one of his 18-yr-old staffers wrote, Oliver hails Macdonald. But what his keen undergraduate hiree doesn’t know, and what Oliver also doesn’t, is that Macdonald was a patriot who was determined to act in Canada ’s interests, not sell them out.) If the Harper government really wanted to stand up for Canada , it would create a national energy strategy in Canada .
Bottom line: